In World War I it was called Shell
Shock and was identified and addressed better than previous wars
in the history of wars. That term continued throughout World War II
and then Korean War.
Today, it is called Post-Traumatic
Stress Disorder, PTSD as an acronym. Simply it is when a
person cannot deal with what they experienced and/or what they saw.
Nicholas
Kristof, pundit for New York Times, stated:
One-quarter of American adults suffer from a diagnosable mental disorder, including depression, anorexia, post-traumatic stress disorder and more, according to the National Institutes of Health. … A parent with depression. A lover who is bipolar. A child with an eating disorder. A brother who returned from war with P.T.S.D. A sister who is suicidal.
Unfortunately, too many are making
temporary depressive situations or normal recall episodes, via
nightmares and something that makes one remember a bad experience;
into an epidemic.
Hollywood, as usual, doesn't make
things better. The film Home of the Brave is a good
example. Everyone of the veterans depicted experience some level of
anti-social behavior and violent actions. It is saying to the public
that this is normal in a false attempt to address the stressed out
combat veterans, but are really just pushing their own opinionated
views on the military in general. The movie has some good points,
mostly from the beginning scenes of the base in Iraq and then the
soldiers of the main story line who are ambushed. It does not depict
our soldiers as ruthless barbarians, although one scene shows a
non-combatant being killed by being in the wrong place – no fault
certainly could be blamed upon the soldier who was the instrument of
that death. But it is a situation where that person involved must
live with that guilt. I made it through the scene of one of the
soldiers going nuts with a handgun in a public place, like we need to
watch that in a film, but when the scene came when the returning
military doctor grabs his handgun (both firearms were M1911 model,
.45-caliber) – then as far as I was concerned the film was over.
Sublimely the writer/producers of this film were included anti-gun
statements – and depicting the same model that people like Senator
Dianne Feinstein wants to ban from public use. Despite her
insistence she understands and knows the Second Amendment, angrily
saying in a congressional hearing that she was not a six-year-old,
she is relentless in not only ignoring the Second Amendment, but not
abiding by her oath of office.
The recent media exposé
of yet another horrific multiple shooting by a deranged KKK racist
at a Jewish community center in Kansas is just more for their gun
control advocate. In reality, the man should not have possessed a
firearm because he had been arrested and convicted of another crime.
So, instead of addressing that problem, the media leads its stories
to other avenues.
Kristof also
addresses this in the aforementioned article:
Indeed,
when the news media do cover mental health, we do so mostly in
extreme situations such as a mass shooting. That leads the public to
think of mental disorders as dangerous, stigmatizing those who are
mentally ill and making it harder for them to find friends or get
family support.
The Institute
of Medicine published (2005) a
paper to address the need to improve
the quality of health care for mental and substance-use conditions:
The report
concluded: although findings of many studies suggest a link between
mental illnesses and violence, the contribution of people with mental
illnesses to overall rate of violence is small.
On the other
end of the spectrum, people could be incorrectly diagnosed and forced
on some mental health program and then lose, forever, the right to
own a firearm.
Americans
commit suicide every year, and while Kristof mistakenly states that
38,000 do so every year, according to the CDC, that number was
in 2010. Credibility is diminished when one claims the same
number of suicides EVERY YEAR. Out of those deaths, 19,292 used
firearms to commit suicide. The CDC also gives suicide by firearms
the highest
rate at 6.3% (2010). While CDC has had a credibility problem from
time to time, we can generally accept that data. I find that FBI
statistics are more reliable.
Kritsof remains
focused upon the mental condition of combat veterans, specifically
for Iraq and Afghanistan veterans, but fails to look at the history
of it. It is also obvious that he does not realize that ALL combat
veterans are stressed during and with different degrees afterwards.
The way pundits and the media in general describe it as though it is
something new with veterans. Today, and as far back as the Vietnam
War that lasted ten years, the combat deployment time is 13 months
for one tour. The Civil War lasted five years and World War II lasted
almost five years. Troops no longer stay until the war is done, as in
Korea War and before, since the Vietnam War because they are lasting
much longer.
They are also
leaving out other stressful situations – like coming home and
feeling so different and not able to relate to even family members,
coming home to unemployment, VA red tape, and politicians reneging
upon their duty to sponsor those they sent to war. Indeed, in the
middle of cutting back military funding when Clinton was president,
and the cost after the Gulf War, Congress sneaked a bill through that
no longer separated retirement income from disability income, which
means they took back what retirement income was promised by deducting
the medical disability benefit from the retirement benefit. This hurt
those who chose the early out program during the Clinton cut back
era; where soldiers received severance pay for choosing the program
and that entire amount has to be deducted before actually receiving a
disability benefit check. So Uncle Sam said, “Hey, we'll give a
check either by the month for twenty years and one lump sum. After
38% tax was taken out, it did not leave as much to use; and when
disability benefit was approved, it was taken back.
It is pathetic
when a government spends billions of dollars for foreign nations and
its people, but cheats its own veterans they have sent to fight other
people's wars.
It is no wonder
that veterans are depressed.
Unfortunately,
like the welfare system, some are taking advantage of the situation.
While others who served have gone through tribulations and stress,
some feel the need, either from weakness or an opportunity to collect
from the system to be declared to have PTSD. That is true for other
“disabilities”. For example, a female veteran receives at least
30% disability for “extreme sinus trouble” and gets herself on a
train for work program.
On the other
side of the spectrum, there are those that should have applied, but
did not out of pride; and others who should have applied sooner.
Another way
Vietnam War and Gulf War vets got shafted was the things with
“syndrome” at the end of the description – Agent Orange and
Gulf War Syndrome. It took almost ten years to recognize the symptoms
were a real medical problem, for some quite severe, to recognize the
Gulf War Syndrome – and then refused to include the period from
mustering out to the approval in benefit evaluation. Instead, they
only counted the time from approval to date. Then, because of the
congressional bill that passed in 1996, any retirement or severance
paid is deducted from that amount. No longer is retirement (or
special program severance pay) separated from disability benefits. It
always seems that the government, those that operate our government,
has a tendency to cut funds where it should not be. It is the same
crowd who sends people off to wars and, because of politics and its
accomplice media, ensure that it is not won or won as quickly as
possible.
Praise is to
President Bush, GW Bush's father, who declared that if troops were to
free Kuwait, they would stay until the war was over. It was over in
100 hours, although there was a long period called Operation
Desert Shield before Operation
Desert Storm.
Although,
despicable Progressive Socialist pundits like Daily
KOS rebukes the idea that some
PTSD claims are either exaggerated or made up – like the veteran
that killed recently at Fort Hood; the US
Naval Institute disagrees, so
do others and myself. As far as Kristof, he has been against
US involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan, so he is biased, as his
sources reveal.
And to fellow
veterans: buck up and if you can't handle the flashbacks or whatever
and deal with it on your own, visit the nearest VA medical facility.
In fact, all of America should visit VA facilities and see what they
are in store for when Obamacare is in full swing.
The VA medical
program and institutions would be much more effective if they tied in
with local hospitals and clinics (and save tax dollars). Except for
psychiatry, don't believe the myth that the local doctor does not
understand about war wounds – all of them must intern in emergency
rooms and all are taught about traumatic wounds and their
repercussions. It would also reduce the long hours in a VA medical
facility that is crowded with veterans from all over the state, and
it will reduce the stress of traveling so far to get the treatment
promised.
To the rest of
fellow Americans – ignore Hollywood films fantasizing and
exaggerating social conditions and those of veterans. After all, it
IS an entertainment entity, despite an occasional honest documentary
film. Films like Stop-Loss
and Home of the Brave
does not depict the average combat veteran, even if the acting is
good.
Veterans from
World War II, those that are still alive, can tell veterans today
that memories of combat and seeing the horrors of the Nazi
concentration camps never totally go away – but has to be dealt
with. The same goes for Korean and Vietnam War veterans – which
they can tell you that those experiencing those traumas and
flashbacks is normal and the percentage of veterans from those wars
who can deal with it seem to be higher than vets of Iraq and
Afghanistan. It may be that the media has pushed that image about
veterans into the minds of the public, because that is what they do
best, besides manipulating or ignoring facts in order to make a point
or match their opinions. Ironically, it is the same media who
presented so much of the negative occurrences enacted by US military
giving a negative image of the overall US combat personnel.
Voters, in this
congressional election year, it is time to clean out Congress of
unconstitutionalists and politicians who send Americans to war and
not keep promises when they return.
No comments:
Post a Comment
No SPAM, please. If you wish to advertise or promote website, contact me.